Scary Story Slumber Party

Jessica Dole

Danielle (segment "The Slumber Party")

Heather Dorff

Becca (segment "Event Invitation")

Jay Gates

Brad (segment "UnLucky Night")

Jackey Hall

Holly (segment "The Dare")

Sierra Holmes

Rachel (segment "UnLucky Night")

Sarah Kaminski

Hilary (segment "The Pledge")

Casey Lane

Party Boy (segment "Noise Complaint")

Rachael Lang

Melissa (segment "The Pledge")

Vince Martinez

Matt (segment: "Backstabber")

Brandon McPherson

Aaron (segment "Noise Complaint")

Jonathan Moody

Tommy (segment Valentine's Prey")

Mathew Moore

Steven (segment "Noise Complaint") / Jeff (segment "Imaginary Fiend")

Amberly Pecsek

Karissa (segment: "Slumber Party"), Courtney (segment: "The Pledge") / Tiffany (segment: "Noise Complaint")

Devanny Pinn

Lindy (segment "Valentine's Prey") / Kate (Segment: "The Pledge")

Brittney Scalf

Brittney (segment "Slumber Party / Grave Misfortune") / Megan (segment "Noise Complaint") / Kristen (segment "Imaginary Fiend") (as Brittney M. Scalf)

Diane Sokolowich

Amy (segment: "Backstabber") / Emma (segment: "Noise Complaint")

Elizabeth Spaetzel

Party Girl (segment "Noise Complaint")

Lindy Starr

Claire (segment: "Noise Complaint") / Jaclyn (segment: "Imaginary Fiend")

Ashley Vetere

Jenna (segment "The Pledge")

DaNae West

Kristen (segment "Bashed")